The Coward Critic

Name                           : Nendi gunawan

NIM                            : 14121320250

Class/semester             : PBI-D/4^th semester

Critical Review

The Coward Critic

Introduction ; 

Zinn, the one of famous  people of United State, there are some people said; Howard Zinn is a  the best person, he is  a historian, a writer, and  a activist, but there are some people also said; Howard Zinn is bad people, he is a slander, he is a radical people. There are so many books that was he made, and all of them  it is to critic about United State, Such as; A people history of united state.  Howard  Zinn is the one Critic of  United state that was disclose also about Columbus’s  story.  In this article I want to critique him work, especially from him artical “Speaking Truth  to Power with Books ”.  There is a point who want to critique from him, such as;  Howard Zinn only wrote about discoverer the United Kingdom is not Columbus, he does not told about the real discoverer from it.

Howar Zinn  was be a famous person, because there are many citizen and people from the another country talk about him. In my point of view he is the brave people, you know why? It is because all of  him work (books) there are so many critic to United state and he was brave to disclose about Americans story. When he was made book A people history of the united state, there are many citizen was talked about him. A people history of the united state explain or to clarify about Columbus’s story, he was change the history of Christopher Columbus.

Summary ;

Speaking Truth to Power with Books, it was explained about Columbus’s story, before Howard  Zinn publish him book,   all citizen of United State has things that found America Kingdom is Christopher Columbus and they are very love  him.  Christopher Columbus, or Cristobal Colón in Spanish, was born in Genoa, Italy, in 1451.

From the children until adult  love him, they said Christopher Columbus is a hero, he is a great people, he found America kingdom, and also they made Columbus day to appreciate him. but there is someone who was killed that statement, he is Howard  Zinn. He  said; the discover American  Kingdom  it is not Christopher Columbus. Actually Christopher Columbus is a bad people, he was killed  many  people, and  also he oftentimes violate some people and the others. Howard  Zinn has made many  books to critic the United State, he oftentimes got many complain,  suggestion, and a critique from the citizen. He is a brave people, but also a coward people. He was disclosed about the discover of United kingdom, but he does not told who the real people that was United Kingdom.

Critique ;

Actually there is some things if we talk about Howard Zinn, the first thing is Howard  Zinn is a brave people, he was disclosed about Christopher Columbus’s story, and also all of  him work it is to critic United State. He was opened  the new history  about the discoverer United  kingdom.  Although there are many problem  that was created from  him work (book), but he keep make books to critic about America Serikat.  For example ; when he made book A people history of united state actually it is many problem. All citizen dislike to him. They are has a think that Howard zinn is bad person, he was talk nonsense. It is not only the citizen but also there are many people from the another country also said like that. They are also dislike to Howard Zinn that was made a bad book.

Second thing is he does not brave to say that the first person who has discovering United  kingdom  is muslim society.  Actually on the history the first society that was found American is a muslim society. All of the Howard Zinn work, the one book of  the negative respond from the citizen is A people history of united state. From that book there are so many people gave dislike respond. Not only from the citizen but also people from the another country.  Howard Zinn said that Christopher Columbus is a bad people. He oftentimes killed, violated, and pillaged goods. In fact the discoverer United Kingdom is Muslim society the one of them is Khashshash bin Said bin Aswad, he found United Kingdom at 889 of Masehi. He is a muslim navigator from Qordoba, Spain. As we know at that time Spain is west civilization islam, leadership by Khilafah Bani Umayah II, but he does told us about it.

In Saga America’s book (New York, 1980) Dr Barr Fell archaeologist from Selandia and graduated from Harvard University told the proof, before Columbus come there, it was there is muslim society from north and west US. In Inyo and California , Dr Barry also found some calligraphy of islam which one wrote in Arabic language, the one of it is “Yesus anak Maria” it means “Isa anak Maryan”, so, this is a proof that muslim have ever lived there. After that, Dr Barry also found about some scripts and diagram or illustrations in the some stone for school activity. That discovering was found in Valley of Fire, Allan Springs, Logomarsino, Keyhole, Canyon Washoe, Hickison Summit Pas (Nevada), Mesa Verde (Colorado), Mimbres Valley (New Mexico) and Tipper Canoe (Indiana). Estimated of all school  was used at  700-800 Masehi. The same information also has wrote by Donald Cyr in him work “Exploring Rock Art (Satna barbara, 1989)”. Africa and the Discovery of Amerika (1920), historian from  Haward University also, Leo Weiner was explained that actually Columbus was know the attendance muslim society in Caribia, north, south America.

Conclusion ;

            Finally the conclution is Howard Zinn is , the one of famous  people from America. There are so many books that was he made, and all of them it is to critic about America Serikat, Such as; A people history of united state. Howard  Zinn is the one Critic of America that was disclose also about Columbus’s story. There are many citizen of America has thing that found America Kingdom is Christopher Columbus and they are very love him. Actually Christopher Columbus is a explorer, he always traveling around the word. From the children until adult  love him, they said Christopher Columbus is a hero, he is a great people, he found America kingdom, and also they made Columbus day to appreciate him. but there is someone who was killed that statement. He is Howard Zinn.

Howard Zinn said ; the discover American Kingdom it is not Christopher Columbus. Actually Christopher Columbus is a bad people, he was killed many people, and also he oftentimes violate some people and others. There is a good and bad thing if talk about Howard Zinn, the good thing is, Howard Zinn is brave people, he was disclosed about Christopher Columbus’s story, and also all of the him work it is to critic America. The bad thing of Howard Zinn is he do not brave to say, that the first person who has discovering America kingdom is muslim society. Actually on the history the first society that was found American is a muslim society.

Referensi ;

Browsing on Tuesday salam-online.com/2014/01/.internet

Speaking Truth to Power With Book (Howard Zinn)

A people history of united state. (Howard Zinn)

Browsing on Monday www.ivanaris.com/2011/03/

Browsing on Tuesday kontroversipenemubenuaamerika.blogspot.com